Practicing the Way by John Mark Comer: Honest Review and Key Takeaways
John Mark Comer is known for addressing the struggles of modern faith with honesty and insight, and his latest book, Practicing the Way, is no exception. In this 2024 release, he invites readers into a deeper, more intentional discipleship by focusing on the rhythms of being with Jesus, becoming like Him, and doing as He did. With practical guidance and reflections grounded in ancient Christian practices, Comer offers an approachable framework for spiritual growth. This book challenges common habits within contemporary faith while emphasizing practices like contemplative prayer, Sabbath-keeping, and community. Whether you’re a longtime believer or exploring faith, Comer’s work prompts a fresh look at what it means to follow Jesus in today’s world.
Who is John Mark Comer?
John Mark Comer is a name that often comes up in conversations about modern Christian living and spiritual practices. Known for his candid insights and accessible approach, he has become an influential voice in today’s faith community. Let’s take a closer look at who he is and why his work resonates with so many.
His Background and Ministry
John Mark Comer was born on June 10, 1980, and spent years as a lead pastor in Portland, Oregon. For nearly two decades, he was the founding pastor of Bridgetown Church, a community that sought to integrate deep spiritual practices into everyday life. His leadership style and focus on spiritual formation attracted a diverse group of people looking for more depth in their faith journey.
In 2020, Comer transitioned away from full-time pastoral ministry to lead a nonprofit organization focused on discipleship and spiritual formation. This shift allowed him to place greater emphasis on teaching individuals how to practice ancient Christian spiritual disciplines in the context of the modern world. You can explore more about his work and ministry through his official website.
Previous Works
Comer has written several books that have shaped how many Christians think about their faith amidst the complexities of modern life. His first major title, Loveology, explored the theology of relationships, marriage, and sexuality. It set the tone for his practical and thoughtful approach to faith-based living.
Perhaps his best-known work is The Ruthless Elimination of Hurry—a book that became a bestseller and continues to resonate with readers. In this book, Comer addresses the cultural obsession with busyness and teaches readers about slowing down and prioritizing what truly matters. Another critical work, Live No Lies, examines the challenges of spiritual warfare in everyday life, encouraging readers to discern truth in a world full of distractions. His latest book, Practicing the Way, builds upon these themes, offering actionable steps to integrate spiritual practices into daily routines. For a full list of his publications, visit his Goodreads author page.
His Influence on Modern Christian Discipleship
John Mark Comer’s teachings bridge the gap between ancient Christian practices and contemporary culture. He brings fresh perspectives to practices like Sabbath-keeping, silence, and contemplative prayer, making them feel relevant in today’s fast-paced society. By doing so, he has inspired both individuals and churches to move beyond surface-level faith into a deeper, more transformational relationship with Jesus.
What sets Comer apart is his vulnerability and honesty. He doesn’t shy away from sharing his own struggles with hurry, distraction, or spiritual dryness. In doing so, he connects with readers who may feel overwhelmed by the pressures of modern life. His simple yet profound guidance often leaves readers asking: How can I live more intentionally in my own faith? For more insights into his recent contributions, check out Christianity Today’s profile on Comer.
By combining personal experience and theological depth, John Mark Comer has created a roadmap for mindful discipleship, making ancient practices accessible for today’s Christians. His impact on spiritual growth continues to ripple across communities worldwide.
The Core Framework of Practicing the Way
John Mark Comer’s Practicing the Way lays out a simple yet profound roadmap for living a life deeply rooted in faith. At its heart, the book presents three core concepts that guide readers in their journey to follow Jesus: Be with Jesus, Become Like Him, and Do as He Did. These pillars represent not just lofty ideals, but actionable practices that can transform everyday living into intentional discipleship. Let’s break these down.
Be with Jesus
At its core, being with Jesus isn’t about following a checklist—it’s about developing a deeply personal relationship with Him. Comer emphasizes practices like prayer, solitude, and consistent communion with God as ways to cultivate this connection. He likens it to the intimacy of a close friendship that requires time, focus, and genuine presence.
One of the key aspects of being with Jesus is creating space for solitude. Comer highlights how Jesus often withdrew to quiet places to pray, modeling an intentional rhythm of rest and reflection. In today’s distracted world, this practice might feel countercultural, but it’s necessary for spiritual renewal. Whether it’s setting aside 10 minutes for silent prayer or dedicating a portion of your day to reading scripture, small practices can help foster moments of connection.
Prayer also plays a foundational role here. Comer explains that prayer isn’t about perfect words, but about vulnerability—bringing your authentic self before God. He encourages readers to approach prayer as a dialogue, not a monologue. This relational posture shifts the focus from performance to presence. Churches and communities often deepen these practices through guided retreats or structured prayer groups, which provide accountability and encouragement.
For a more detailed perspective on practicing solitude and prayer in modern faith, check out this article on spiritual transformation.
Become Like Him
Spiritual growth is a process, not a destination, and Practicing the Way offers clear steps for becoming more like Jesus. Comer encourages readers to adopt what he calls a “Rule of Life,” a set of habits and disciplines designed to align one’s character with Christ. The idea isn’t to strive for perfection, but to allow transformation to happen from the inside out.
Comer stresses the importance of consistency. Just as repeated exercise transforms the body, practicing daily spiritual habits like forgiveness, humility, and gratitude gradually shapes the soul. These practices are not just moral ideals—they’re essential tools for deep, meaningful change. Comer invites readers to see these habits as seeds planted in the soil of their spirit, which will eventually bloom into Christ-like character.
If you’re wondering where to start, Comer suggests beginning with small, manageable steps. For example, practicing gratitude by journaling three things you’re thankful for every evening. Over time, these seemingly minor rituals build a foundation of joy and peace. For additional guidance on arranging your life for spiritual transformation, you can explore resources like this guide on creating lasting spiritual disciplines.
Do as He Did
Faith isn’t just about belief—it’s about action. In the final pillar of his framework, Comer calls readers to live out Jesus’ teachings in tangible ways. This includes serving others, showing generosity, and bringing faith into everyday actions. Comer reminds us that Jesus spent much of His life ministering to the marginalized, healing the sick, and feeding the hungry. Followers are called to reflect this same spirit of service.
Rather than seeing service as an obligation, Comer frames it as a joyful response to God’s love. Helping a neighbor, volunteering in your local community, or listening to someone in need—these are all simple ways to embody Jesus’ teachings. Generosity, likewise, is about more than finances; it’s about giving your time, attention, and resources to reflect God’s heart.
Comer also emphasizes the importance of sharing faith naturally, not as a scripted conversation but as part of how you live your life. Whether through kindness, honesty, or integrity in work and relationships, these daily actions preach the gospel more loudly than words ever could. For those looking for additional inspiration, the book reviews from Missionary Life delve deeper into how serving others mirrors Jesus’ way of life.
Together, these three practices—being with Jesus, becoming like Him, and doing as He did—create a comprehensive framework for intentional discipleship that is both practical and deeply impactful.
Key Strengths of the Book
John Mark Comer’s Practicing the Way positions itself as a guide for those seeking to follow Jesus with depth and intentionality. The book is praised for its practical wisdom, insightful theology, and ability to address contemporary challenges to faith. Readers will find numerous strengths that make this book not just a good read but a transforming experience.
Practical and Actionable Guidance
One of the main appeals of this book is its hands-on approach. Comer isn’t just writing about spiritual growth; he provides readers with tangible steps to integrate spiritual practices into daily routines. Whether it’s keeping the Sabbath, practicing silent prayer, or building a Rule of Life, his suggestions are clear, accessible, and realistic for modern readers. Rather than overwhelming readers with impossible standards, he lays out doable practices that feel more like tools and less like burdens.
By using examples from his own life and ministry, Comer creates a relatable roadmap. He writes not as a detached expert but as someone walking alongside the reader. His focus on progress—not perfection—makes this book especially inviting to those who might feel burnt out or unsure about where to start.
For a deeper dive into how Comer structures these practices, check out this thoughtful review and summary.
Theological Depth with Accessibility
While packed with theological insights, Practicing the Way avoids complicated jargon. Comer has a gift for taking complex spiritual ideas and making them approachable for everyday readers. His framework—“Be with Jesus, Become Like Him, Do as He Did”—summarizes Jesus’ teachings in a way that feels both fresh and rooted in tradition. This simplicity resonates with readers regardless of their theological background or level of spiritual maturity.
Yet, simplicity doesn’t mean shallow. Comer brings richness to the table by incorporating ideas from diverse faith traditions, including mystical, monastic, and charismatic practices. Drawing inspiration from thinkers like Dallas Willard and Henri Nouwen, he builds on solid spiritual foundations while making them applicable to today’s context. For those seeking a bridge between traditional Christianity and modern-day challenges, this thoughtful integration is a breath of fresh air.
Addressing Modern Spiritual Challenges
In a world dominated by busyness, consumerism, and constant distractions, Comer speaks directly to the cultural obstacles that hinder spiritual growth. He doesn’t shy away from addressing uncomfortable truths about the ways modern lifestyles conflict with faith. For example, his emphasis on slowing down and creating unhurried rhythms pushes against the pressure to always do more, achieve more, and be more.
The book’s insights into combating digital distractions and shallow faith practices are especially timely. Comer encourages readers to counteract these influences through intentional disciplines, offering alternatives that foster stillness, reflection, and authenticity. His approach feels countercultural—as if he’s gently daring readers to embrace a different way of living.
For more on how the book reflects on societal issues and discipleship, take a look at this insight from Premier Christianity.
Relational and Community-Centric
Comer emphasizes the role of relationships—not just individual effort—in spiritual growth. He acknowledges that faith flourishes within the context of a supportive community, a vital reminder in an era where isolation is common. Practices like hospitality, accountability groups, and communal rhythms are all explored, helping Christians prioritize relationships in their walk with Christ.
In this sense, Practicing the Way isn’t just a personal discipleship guide—it’s an invitation to live out faith alongside others. The shift from “me” to “we” that Comer promotes could be a game-changer for many readers seeking to deepen their faith through shared experiences and collective practices.
If you’re curious about how Comer weaves together community and discipleship, this review offers useful insights.
Culturally Relevant Yet Timeless
Balancing timeless truths with cultural relevance is no easy task, but Comer handles it with care. Rather than diminishing the gospel’s essence, he amplifies it by showing how ancient traditions still speak to today’s world. The focus on creating what he calls a “Rule of Life”—an intentional pattern of habits and practices—is deeply rooted in history yet profoundly relevant to today’s challenges.
Whether he’s discussing fasting, prayer, or generosity, the point remains clear: these aren’t outdated or irrelevant acts but essential lifelines for navigating modern struggles. The book connects deeply with readers navigating faith in an era where traditional practices might otherwise feel disconnected or impractical.
For further context on how Comer balances cultural and spiritual themes, this review discusses this dynamic well.
Inviting Tone and Personal Vulnerability
Finally, what sets Practicing the Way apart is Comer’s vulnerability. He openly shares his own struggles, doubts, and setbacks, making the book feel more like a conversation than a lecture. His honesty puts readers at ease, especially for those intimidated by the idea of perfection in discipleship. Comer admits he’s still learning and invites readers to join him on the journey rather than follow behind at a distance.
This warm, inviting tone keeps the book engaging while delivering its challenges. Instead of feeling pressured to meet impossible standards, readers walk away encouraged to take small, faithful steps with grace and determination.
In summary, the book stands out for its practicality, clarity, cultural relevance, and relational focus, making it a valuable companion for Christians seeking a deeper, more intentional walk with Jesus.
Potential Limitations and Criticisms
Every book has its strengths, but it’s important to also consider where it might fall short. While Practicing the Way by John Mark Comer brings inspiring ideas and practical ways to deepen one’s faith, not everyone fully embraces it. Some readers have raised thoughtful criticisms that are worth exploring. Here’s a closer look at the book’s potential limitations.
Overemphasis on Spiritual Practices
One of the main concerns brought up by critics is that Comer appears to put significant weight on spiritual disciplines, almost to the point of overshadowing the concept of grace. While his emphasis on practices like prayer, fasting, and Sabbath is clearly meant to guide readers into deeper faith, some feel this focus risks making faith look too much like a “self-help program” rather than the result of spiritual regeneration.
This critique highlights the balance between doing and being in one’s walk with Christ. The spiritual disciplines Comer advocates are undeniably important, but could some readers interpret this as a to-do list for achieving holiness? For a deeper dive on this concern, check out this analysis from Lighthouse Trails.
Limited Focus on Gospel Proclamation
Another criticism is the book’s emphasis on practices over proclamation. In Practicing the Way, much of the guidance centers on personal growth and spiritual disciplines. While these are life-giving and transformative, some readers feel Comer doesn’t talk enough about sharing the gospel beyond personal actions.
Yes, good deeds do reflect faith, but critics argue that explicit conversations about sharing the gospel message are missing or underplayed in the framework. As one reviewer pointed out, it’s unclear how these practices translate to evangelistic efforts or advancing God’s mission globally. For further thoughts on this, take a look at this review from The Gospel Coalition.
Downplaying Conversion Experiences
Some readers have mentioned that Comer’s book seems to focus largely on long-term discipleship, leaving questions about the initial call to faith or conversion. While the spiritual practices Comer discusses are helpful tools for growth, they primarily speak to those already in the faith. Critics argue this approach may unintentionally assume a starting point rather than addressing what it means to begin practicing the way of Jesus.
For those outside the faith or new to Christianity, the book might feel slightly disconnected from the broader gospel message. Is there enough emphasis on what comes before practicing—acknowledging Jesus as Savior? You can explore a deeper reflection on this in this critical review.
Lack of Global Perspective
While Comer beautifully captures the individual and communal aspects of practicing faith, some feel the book lacks a global perspective. Christianity is a worldwide movement with diverse expressions, but Practicing the Way focuses mainly on practices relatable to Western readers. Critics point out there’s little discussion on how these disciplines translate to cultures or contexts outside the Western world.
This doesn’t mean the practices are irrelevant elsewhere, but explaining how they adapt across cultural lines could make the book more inclusive. For a broader look at this issue, this critique highlights more about how the book could expand its global view.
Risks of Legalism
Lastly, there’s a concern that readers might misinterpret Comer’s framework as rigid or obligatory. Though that’s not his intent, when concepts like habitual disciplines and a “Rule of Life” are introduced, they can sometimes be seen as boxes to check rather than tools for spiritual freedom. This risk of unintended legalism might discourage readers who already struggle with feeling like they’re “not doing enough.”
While Comer emphasizes grace and progress over perfection, not every reader may pick up on this nuance. As one critique suggests, understanding that spiritual practices are means, not ends, is crucial to benefiting from Comer’s approach. This point is touched on in this insightful review on Challies.
By exploring these criticisms, we see that while Practicing the Way offers a compelling and helpful vision for discipleship, it’s also vital to weigh these perspectives. Each point encourages thoughtful reading and ensures the application of Comer’s ideas aligns with the reader’s faith journey.
How Practicing the Way Fits Into Modern Christian Discipleship
Modern Christian discipleship often feels like juggling too many priorities. Between navigating a fast-paced world, staying committed to faith, and building meaningful relationships, many Christians struggle to find consistent practices that ground them spiritually. John Mark Comer’s Practicing the Way bridges this gap by offering a roadmap back to ancient practices that cultivate deeper discipleship. His approach isn’t about adding more to your plate—it’s about finding purpose and rhythm in the everyday. Here’s how Comer’s insights refresh and reshape what it means to follow Christ today.
Addressing the Crisis of Shallow Faith
One of the big challenges facing churches today is what many call a “discipleship crisis.” People attend services, sing worship songs, and leave unchanged. Comer points out that too often, we stop at information when transformation is what truly matters. Practicing the Way appeals directly to this shortfall by reintroducing spiritual disciplines—ancient practices like Sabbath-keeping, fasting, and prayer—as tools for meaningful growth.
Comer argues that the Western church has become overly reliant on knowledge, neglecting the lived experience of faith. By emphasizing habits that Jesus Himself practiced, like solitude and acts of service, discipleship becomes more than intellectual—it becomes a tangible response to God’s love. In a culture consumed by busyness, these disciplines cut through the noise with simplicity and focus. For more on why this is so relevant today, check out this article on rising spiritual openness.
Three Pillars Rooted in Practicality
Comer’s framework—Be with Jesus, Become Like Him, Do as He Did—is as simple as it is profound. Each pillar builds on the other, turning faith from a Sunday morning activity into a daily practice. But what makes them resonate so deeply with modern Christians?
- Be with Jesus: This is about prioritizing a personal relationship with Christ, not just out of obligation but out of genuine desire. Practices like silent prayer and scripture meditation anchor believers in God’s presence.
- Become Like Him: Transformation happens through habits. Comer’s “Rule of Life” encourages setting up intentional routines—whether gratitude journaling or fasting—with the purpose of reflecting Christ’s character.
- Do as He Did: Discipleship doesn’t stop at personal growth. It extends outward, asking believers to serve their communities, live generously, and share the Gospel authentically.
What’s unique here is that Comer doesn’t just suggest ideas; he provides tools and guidance to implement them. It’s not about perfection but daily progress, making these practices accessible even to those new in faith. You can read more about this framework’s application in churches in this analysis by The Gospel Coalition.
Reflecting Current Trends in Spiritual Growth
In recent years, spiritual formation practices have seen a revival as Christians seek more intentional faith habits. Concepts like minimalism, mindfulness, and Sabbath trends in secular culture echo many of the disciplines Comer advocates. This alignment with broader societal movements gives his approach an appealing touchpoint for those both inside and outside the church.
Recent studies also show that while church attendance might decline, spiritual openness is rising. More people are hungry for authenticity in faith practices rather than performances. Comer’s emphasis on slowing down, embracing rest, and practicing simplicity strikes a chord with this trend. He’s essentially reframing ancient spiritual disciplines in light of today’s chaotic rhythms, helping believers connect with God in a deeper, more actionable way.
If you’re curious about how these trends are shaping faith communities, check out this resource on current cultural and spiritual shifts.
Bridging the Gap Between Individual and Community Faith
Another key takeaway from Practicing the Way is how Comer balances the personal and communal aspects of discipleship. While modern culture often promotes individualism, Comer reminds readers that faith grows best in relationships. Practices like Sabbath dinners, accountability groups, and shared spiritual disciplines reinforce the idea that transformation often happens in community.
This emphasis addresses the growing preference for small, tight-knit church groups over large, impersonal gatherings. As highlighted in this Lifeway study, community-focused approaches are gaining traction, providing better spiritual support for today’s seekers and believers. Comer’s call for communal discipleship enhances rather than replaces individual spiritual practices, making faith both relatable and collective.
By blending timeless practices with modern insights, Practicing the Way reinvigorates discipleship for a generation hungry for authenticity and purpose. It’s not just a framework—it’s an invitation to reimagine what it means to follow Jesus today.
Conclusion
Practicing the Way by John Mark Comer inspires Christians looking to deepen their faith in practical, meaningful ways. Its emphasis on spiritual disciplines like prayer, Sabbath, and service offers a refreshing path toward intentional discipleship. By presenting a framework that’s both accessible and rooted in tradition, the book meets the needs of those seeking more depth in their relationship with Christ.
While some readers may question its balance of practice and gospel proclamation, the overall message encourages taking small, faithful steps toward transformation. It’s a reminder that discipleship isn’t about perfection but progress, grounded in grace.
If you’re ready to slow down, refocus, and rethink what it means to follow Jesus, this book is a great starting point. What practices could you incorporate into your own life to bring you closer to Him?
